Each guide answers one question and hands you the calculator that does the arithmetic. Each study states what was asked, how it was measured and what came back. Every one takes a position in its first line.
Three groups, and the difference between them is not the topic but how much of the answer is decidable.
| Group | What can be settled |
|---|---|
| Risk and position sizing | Entirely. These are arithmetic — the answer is derivable and does not depend on any market behaving a particular way |
| Method | Mostly. What makes a test trustworthy is a matter of design rather than of results |
| Candlesticks and patterns | Partly. The rules and their invalidation conditions are published; the measured outcomes are withheld while the study is re-run |
The first group is where almost all of the practical value sits, and it is the group that requires no research to be finished. Position size, expectancy and the drawdown arithmetic decide more outcomes than any pattern does, and all three are settled by you rather than by the market.
Each guide shows the formula, works an example through it with numbers you can check on the matching calculator, and states what the arithmetic ignores. Where a claim depends on a measurement, it says which measurement and whether it is currently published.
Worth knowing
None of these guides quotes a hit rate for a candlestick formation, because none is currently publishable. The run that would supply one was computed on a superseded engine and withdrawn rather than published with a caveat.
In this order, because each one is an input to the next and reading them out of order makes the later ones look arbitrary:
Every one follows the same shape, and the shape is the point rather than a house style.
Three come up constantly and are absent on purpose, because answering them well is not possible and answering them badly is easy.
| Question | Why it is not answered |
|---|---|
| Which strategy should I trade | It depends on capital, horizon and what you can hold through a losing run — none of which a page can know |
| What is the best indicator setting | Any specific answer is a parameter chosen on someone else's data, which is the definition of overfitting |
| Should I take this trade | A calculator can price a trade. Whether the setup is worth taking is not arithmetic |
What the guides do instead is make the arithmetic explicit enough that you can answer those yourself, and see what your answer depends on.